Just by way of a heads up: I recently bought some "food grade" hydrochloric acid from 'solvent-shop' on ebay for water-treatment. When it arrived there was nothing at all on the container that indicated it was food grade so I asked them about this; apparently they consider it suitable for use around food (like cleaning food-making machinery) but tell me it is 'not' suitable for ingestion.
In fact they seemed unaware there even are any grades of hydrochloric acid that could be used in food itself. So my understanding of 'food grade' hydrochloric and theirs is clearly not the same, and it seems deeply unlikely that this product complies with E507 or any other food-additive level of specification. How bad it actually is if ingested I've no idea, but thought it worth a mention. Mine looks set for patio-cleaning duties.
'Food grade' hydrochloric acid - that isn't
-
- Drunk as a Skunk
- Posts: 904
- Joined: Tue Jan 15, 2013 11:42 am
- Location: Newton-le-Willows ( St Helens/Warrington)
Re: 'Food grade' hydrochloric acid - that isn't
thats food contact not food grade.
try for analar or arastar lab grades.
aamcle
try for analar or arastar lab grades.
aamcle
Re: 'Food grade' hydrochloric acid - that isn't
I'm guessing it might be worth stocking up given the recent spate of attacks and the impending knee-jerk reaction.
- Kev888
- So far gone I'm on the way back again!
- Posts: 7701
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2010 6:22 pm
- Location: Derbyshire, UK
Re: 'Food grade' hydrochloric acid - that isn't
Yes, that was the motivation for my order. They seem to be suggesting that people can simply use bleach instead, well.. not in this case. Thankfully a little acid goes a long way for treating my tap water, so a modest amount should give me a few years to get into the use of RO water or other/weaker acids, should that become necessary long term.
Fortunately another seller, APC pure, does sell truly food grade hydrochloric to the EU's E507 specification, and so I now have some of that. Their postage is a bit costly but then they use APC overnight who can presumably deal safely with such things and (at least for me) seem to deliver when specified (solvent-shop sent theirs in an unmarked box via Yodel, and the next day delivery took three days).
Yes, it certainly isn't food grade by any definition that I believe. Either way though, I'm just pleased that I checked what they mean by it.aamcle wrote:thats food contact not food grade.
Fortunately another seller, APC pure, does sell truly food grade hydrochloric to the EU's E507 specification, and so I now have some of that. Their postage is a bit costly but then they use APC overnight who can presumably deal safely with such things and (at least for me) seem to deliver when specified (solvent-shop sent theirs in an unmarked box via Yodel, and the next day delivery took three days).
Kev
Re: 'Food grade' hydrochloric acid - that isn't
Excuse my ignorance but is food grade just very high purity in this instance?
- Kev888
- So far gone I'm on the way back again!
- Posts: 7701
- Joined: Fri Mar 19, 2010 6:22 pm
- Location: Derbyshire, UK
Re: 'Food grade' hydrochloric acid - that isn't
Yes, I believe it is pretty much about the purity; less than a specified amount of things like arsenic, lead, mercury, organic matter, oxidising substances and so on. It doesn't imply that (for example) concentrated acid is safe to drink 'as is', just that when used appropriately the levels of contaminants will be acceptable.
Obviously, we tend to dilute these things heavily so in practice (and at our own risk) could probably get away with slightly higher levels of impurity. EDIT: I've taken this stance with my 'nearly' food grade sulphuric acid, since I couldn't find any truly food grade stuff that was available for public purchase (the higher concentrations aren't either). It isn't impossible that the solvent shop hydrochloric would do too. But personally I'd want a specification and evidence of quality assurance before I intentionally use any acid in my beer, and that isn't always forthcoming with some of the lesser grades. Otherwise if it was just intended for batteries or something who knows what could be in there?
Obviously, we tend to dilute these things heavily so in practice (and at our own risk) could probably get away with slightly higher levels of impurity. EDIT: I've taken this stance with my 'nearly' food grade sulphuric acid, since I couldn't find any truly food grade stuff that was available for public purchase (the higher concentrations aren't either). It isn't impossible that the solvent shop hydrochloric would do too. But personally I'd want a specification and evidence of quality assurance before I intentionally use any acid in my beer, and that isn't always forthcoming with some of the lesser grades. Otherwise if it was just intended for batteries or something who knows what could be in there?
Kev