Sorry if i'm off topic!!
On about water? The water where I live at Wombwell is crap, I do believe it's from bore holes with a very high p.h.
I get a TCP smell next day if water is left overnight in a glass after a session on the ale.
I had loads of bad mashes with the conversion of fermentable sugars, then 2 days after yeast was pitched the wort would look dead with hardly any signs of life, as anybody else noticed the wort looking "dead" or is it just me?
The lighter the beer colour the more failures, the only brews I could do was with 2lb of crushed crystal in with the crushed malt.
I Tried boiling with citric acid, water salts, gypsum, epson salts, you name it I tried it. (made me jack in 10yrs ago)
When I brew now I source the water from work, I think it is on Sheffield supply from the pennines, I don't add anything to the mash liquor and the beers have been great (light & dark).
The best advice I could give to anybody about brewing is check your water, get a p.h tester, try different supplies near to home, I'm only 7 miles from work but a totally different supply!
John