Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
- Deebee
- Even further under the Table
- Posts: 2324
- Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 9:13 am
- Location: Mid North West Norway
Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
Hi all.
After having been home over the summer i am desperate for a good beef and ale pie recipe.
i ate some at a restaurant. one was so disgusting i never got past the crust. the second was so dry it was like the bottom of a dried sausepan in pastry, the last was absolutely f*cking amazing but the chef refused to let me have the recipe .. git.
So i appeal to all of you who may wish to help an ex pat out here.. please.. there are so many recipies online but i want something tried and tested. Ale is something i have in many different varieties.
Thanks
After having been home over the summer i am desperate for a good beef and ale pie recipe.
i ate some at a restaurant. one was so disgusting i never got past the crust. the second was so dry it was like the bottom of a dried sausepan in pastry, the last was absolutely f*cking amazing but the chef refused to let me have the recipe .. git.
So i appeal to all of you who may wish to help an ex pat out here.. please.. there are so many recipies online but i want something tried and tested. Ale is something i have in many different varieties.
Thanks
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
I just make a nice thick beef and ale stew and use this for the pie filling. Usually just brown the meat off (braising steak) season well, add chopped onions (or shallots if I have them) and diced carrots, fry off a little more, crumble in a beef stock cube and then cover with beer (usually something dark(ish)). Lid on the casserole dish and then in to the oven for at least 3 hours at around 160 degrees. Take the lid off for last half hour of cooking if there is still a bit too much liquid so that it can evaporate and thicken. You can make this the day before and refrigerate overnight.
Do you need a full recipe? Pastry too??
Do you need a full recipe? Pastry too??
Last edited by Mr. Dripping on Wed Aug 06, 2014 10:35 am, edited 1 time in total.
- Deebee
- Even further under the Table
- Posts: 2324
- Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 9:13 am
- Location: Mid North West Norway
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
No pastry is ok. I always thought that i needed to marinade the beef in ale thoughMr. Dripping wrote:I just make a nice thick beef and ale stew and use this for the pie filling. Usually just brown the meat off (braising steak) season well, add chopped onions (or shallots if I have them) and diced carrots, fry off a little more, crumble in a beef stock cube and then cover with beer (usually something dark(ish)). Lid on the casserole dish and then in to the oven for at least 3 hours at around 160 degrees. Take the lid off for last half hour of cooking is there is still a bit too much liquid so that it can evaporate and thicken. You can make this the day before and refrigerate overnight.
Do you need a full recipe? Pastry too??
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
I've never done that Deebee. Just use the ale in place of water / liquid stock.
- Deebee
- Even further under the Table
- Posts: 2324
- Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 9:13 am
- Location: Mid North West Norway
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
roll on the weekend!Mr. Dripping wrote:I've never done that Deebee. Just use the ale in place of water / liquid stock.
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
The one on the BBC website is good I've done that one a few times
Cheers and gone,
Mozza
Mozza
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
I do the same as Mr Dripping.
A handful of flour (normal or cornstarch - and a quick stir) just before the stock goes in will help it thicken nicely.
A handful of flour (normal or cornstarch - and a quick stir) just before the stock goes in will help it thicken nicely.
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
Hi Dave
I must admit I've never followed their recipe (at the end) ... but I do find the way that that article from the Guardian (link) shows all its "working out", discussing the pros and cons of the different options, makes an interesting read
I suppose, as when brewing beer, getting this right is too important to just accept someone else's recipe. You should recognise "Beef and Ale Pie" not merely as a simple foodstuff, but as a "style" of food, and you need to consider what sort of pie you intended to make, within the "style guidelines"
Cheers, PhilB
I must admit I've never followed their recipe (at the end) ... but I do find the way that that article from the Guardian (link) shows all its "working out", discussing the pros and cons of the different options, makes an interesting read
I suppose, as when brewing beer, getting this right is too important to just accept someone else's recipe. You should recognise "Beef and Ale Pie" not merely as a simple foodstuff, but as a "style" of food, and you need to consider what sort of pie you intended to make, within the "style guidelines"
Cheers, PhilB
- Deebee
- Even further under the Table
- Posts: 2324
- Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 9:13 am
- Location: Mid North West Norway
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
he he never been one to care about style guidelines mate. So i will make the ppie and as long as it is edible i am happy... wont be doing a 25 litre batch though:)PhilB wrote:Hi Dave
I must admit I've never followed their recipe (at the end) ... but I do find the way that that article from the Guardian (link) shows all its "working out", discussing the pros and cons of the different options, makes an interesting read
I suppose, as when brewing beer, getting this right is too important to just accept someone else's recipe. You should recognise "Beef and Ale Pie" not merely as a simple foodstuff, but as a "style" of food, and you need to consider what sort of pie you intended to make, within the "style guidelines"
Cheers, PhilB
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
I make a very good ale pie this way (1) marinade meat over night after you have seasoned it in a good strong ale (2) fry onion (3) part boil carrot and celery (4) make a stock using boul beef stock (5) combine all together using some of your ale , using corn flour to thicken the last of your ale place in a dish adding a good thick pastry crust (you could use suet for a change )
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
Thyme, and a couple of anchovies, for seasoning and the umami boost. Star Anise when browning the meat, apparently enhances the beefiness, according to Heston Blooming'ell.
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
My missus makes a damn fine steak and ale pie. 'Secret' ingredients include....a bay leaf, black pudding, a pint of my homebrew stout and a pork chop. Cook the filling for as long as possible so the meat is utterly melting.
- Deebee
- Even further under the Table
- Posts: 2324
- Joined: Thu May 21, 2009 9:13 am
- Location: Mid North West Norway
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
So a 25 litre batch it is then:)
thanks for the help gents
thanks for the help gents
- DeGarre
- Lost in an Alcoholic Haze
- Posts: 512
- Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2011 7:04 pm
- Location: County Durham
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
For the crust I do 5 parts flour to 4 parts butter. It needs to be flaky and buttery.
Re: Beef and Ale pie recipe needed desperately
This is one of my favourite dishes!
A couple of tips (from the Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall 'MEAT' book I use a lot):
Use good quality braising/stewing beef and coat it in flour which has been seasoned with salt and pepper.
Fry it off in a HOT!! pan with some regular oil in the bottom, so that the meat properly browns, don't crowd the pan else it will strew in its own juices. Do it in batches if necassary. You need to 'caramelise' the meat as thats wher ethe flavour comes from.
Spoon it out into a bowl and then turn the heat down for frying your onions, carrots, bay leaves etc as others have suggested.
Throw the meat back into the pan, cover it in a decent beer and a dollop of good stock and chuck it in the over at around 160C for a couple of hours.
When done let it cool.
The following day, make your pie as you would normally, it'll be gorgeous.
Don't forget to pick out the bay leaves though...
A couple of tips (from the Hugh Fearnley Whittingstall 'MEAT' book I use a lot):
Use good quality braising/stewing beef and coat it in flour which has been seasoned with salt and pepper.
Fry it off in a HOT!! pan with some regular oil in the bottom, so that the meat properly browns, don't crowd the pan else it will strew in its own juices. Do it in batches if necassary. You need to 'caramelise' the meat as thats wher ethe flavour comes from.
Spoon it out into a bowl and then turn the heat down for frying your onions, carrots, bay leaves etc as others have suggested.
Throw the meat back into the pan, cover it in a decent beer and a dollop of good stock and chuck it in the over at around 160C for a couple of hours.
When done let it cool.
The following day, make your pie as you would normally, it'll be gorgeous.
Don't forget to pick out the bay leaves though...