Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
Anecdotally, we home brewers chronically underpitch.
If I'm using wet yeast, I rely on the calculator in brewfather to tell me how big my starter should be (e.g. 1050 OG Dunkelweiss this weekend with a pack of WLP300 is using a 0.9L starter).
If using dry yeast, I don't always follow what Brewfather tells me (e.g. brewed a 1050 OG Helles with MJ Bohemian Lager yeast and pitched 2 packs c.f. the 3 that BF "told" me to use. It fermented just fine thank you very much).
Relying on a 5 month old smack pack to ferment 20L of 1048 ale seems optimistic, though, but I'd reckon that a single pack of S-04 ought to cope OK, albeit the lag time may be 24 hours or so.
If I'm using wet yeast, I rely on the calculator in brewfather to tell me how big my starter should be (e.g. 1050 OG Dunkelweiss this weekend with a pack of WLP300 is using a 0.9L starter).
If using dry yeast, I don't always follow what Brewfather tells me (e.g. brewed a 1050 OG Helles with MJ Bohemian Lager yeast and pitched 2 packs c.f. the 3 that BF "told" me to use. It fermented just fine thank you very much).
Relying on a 5 month old smack pack to ferment 20L of 1048 ale seems optimistic, though, but I'd reckon that a single pack of S-04 ought to cope OK, albeit the lag time may be 24 hours or so.
Fermenting: Cherry lambic
Conditioning: English IPA/Bretted English IPA, Munich Helles, straight lambic
Drinking: Munich Dunkel, Helles Bock, Orval clone, Impy stout, Porter 2, Hazelweiss 2024, historic London Porter
Planning: Kozel dark (ish),and more!
Conditioning: English IPA/Bretted English IPA, Munich Helles, straight lambic
Drinking: Munich Dunkel, Helles Bock, Orval clone, Impy stout, Porter 2, Hazelweiss 2024, historic London Porter
Planning: Kozel dark (ish),and more!
-
- Tippler
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2020 4:20 pm
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
I like to avoid lag times, stressed yeast & unwanted flavours in my beers.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
- Even further under the Table
- Posts: 2717
- Joined: Mon Mar 22, 2010 7:10 pm
- Location: Christchurch, Dorset
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
How can you avoid a lag time? Surely the yeast, whether wet or dried, whether starter or not, needs to use up the oxygen in the wort before beginning to ferment the sugars?Bretty Biscuit wrote: ↑Thu Nov 26, 2020 6:47 pmI like to avoid lag times, stressed yeast & unwanted flavours in my beers.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Guy
-
- Tippler
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2020 4:20 pm
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
[quote="guypettigrew"][quote="Bretty Biscuit" post_id=853897 time=1606412857 user_id=31558]
I like to avoid lag times, stressed yeast & unwanted flavours in my beers.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
[/quote]
How can you avoid a lag time? Surely the yeast, whether wet or dried, whether starter or not, needs to use up the oxygen in the wort before beginning to ferment the sugars?
Guy[/quote]
It can be avoided by pitching the correct amount of yeast, within recommended temp & good oxygenation. Lagers can appear to lag as they’re brewed at much lower temps than Ale, lager yeast strains bottom ferment too. Just because the airlock ( if using) doesn’t bubble does not mean there is no activity.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I like to avoid lag times, stressed yeast & unwanted flavours in my beers.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
[/quote]
How can you avoid a lag time? Surely the yeast, whether wet or dried, whether starter or not, needs to use up the oxygen in the wort before beginning to ferment the sugars?
Guy[/quote]
It can be avoided by pitching the correct amount of yeast, within recommended temp & good oxygenation. Lagers can appear to lag as they’re brewed at much lower temps than Ale, lager yeast strains bottom ferment too. Just because the airlock ( if using) doesn’t bubble does not mean there is no activity.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
Yeah, anyway, the so-called lag phase is simply where the yeast cells need time to process the environmental change - sweet wort conditions - and remodel their transcriptome to synthesise the appropriate proteins (enzymes) to do their dirty deed. It takes a few to several hours under optimal conditions, being strain dependent. Any longer, you’ve f*cked up somewhere in the process. The longer your ‘lag phase’ the more you’ve f*cked up. It doesn’t take f*cking days. Fermentation takes days. The biggest f*ck ups are under pitching and low viability, which aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive f*ck ups. The main aim is to pitch sufficient (lots of) healthy yeast cells. There aren’t any magic one-size-fits-all pitching rates* and home brewers are unlikely to be in a position to be ‘over pitching’.
*How the f*ck are you going to know, unless you have at least a microscope and you really know how to use it?
*How the f*ck are you going to know, unless you have at least a microscope and you really know how to use it?

- Trefoyl
- Even further under the Table
- Posts: 2540
- Joined: Mon Nov 09, 2009 5:28 pm
- Location: New Jersey
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
McMullan wrote: ↑Thu Nov 26, 2020 9:41 pmYeah, anyway, the so-called lag phase is simply where the yeast cells need time to process the environmental change - sweet wort conditions - and remodel their transcriptome to synthesise the appropriate proteins (enzymes) to do their dirty deed. It takes a few to several hours under optimal conditions, being strain dependent. Any longer, you’ve f*cked up somewhere in the process. The longer your ‘lag phase’ the more you’ve f*cked up. It doesn’t take f*cking days. Fermentation takes days. The biggest f*ck ups are under pitching and low viability, which aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive f*ck ups. The main aim is to pitch sufficient (lots of) healthy yeast cells. There aren’t any magic one-size-fits-all pitching rates* and home brewers are unlikely to be in a position to be ‘over pitching’.
*How the f*ck are you going to know, unless you have at least a microscope and you really know how to use it?![]()

Sommeliers recommend that you swirl a glass of wine and inhale its bouquet before throwing it in the face of your enemy.
-
- Tippler
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2020 4:20 pm
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
[quote="McMullan"]Yeah, anyway, the so-called [i]lag phase[/i] is simply where the yeast cells need time to process the environmental change - sweet wort conditions - and remodel their transcriptome to synthesise the appropriate proteins (enzymes) to do their dirty deed. It takes a few to several hours under optimal conditions, being strain dependent. Any longer, you’ve f*cked up somewhere in the process. The longer your ‘lag phase’ the more you’ve f*cked up. It doesn’t take f*cking days. [i]Fermentation[/i] takes days. The biggest f*ck ups are under pitching and low viability, which aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive f*ck ups. The main aim is to pitch sufficient (lots of) healthy yeast cells. There aren’t any magic one-size-fits-all pitching rates* and home brewers are unlikely to be in a position to be ‘over pitching’.
*How the f*ck are you going to know, unless you have at least a microscope and you really know how to use it? :lol:[/quote]
[IMG]https://media2.giphy.com/media/10UHehEC098kAE/giphy.gif[/IMG]
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
*How the f*ck are you going to know, unless you have at least a microscope and you really know how to use it? :lol:[/quote]
[IMG]https://media2.giphy.com/media/10UHehEC098kAE/giphy.gif[/IMG]
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
-
- Tippler
- Posts: 19
- Joined: Tue Oct 13, 2020 4:20 pm
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
[quote="Trefoyl"][quote=McMullan post_id=853901 time=1606423279 user_id=15744]
Yeah, anyway, the so-called [i]lag phase[/i] is simply where the yeast cells need time to process the environmental change - sweet wort conditions - and remodel their transcriptome to synthesise the appropriate proteins (enzymes) to do their dirty deed. It takes a few to several hours under optimal conditions, being strain dependent. Any longer, you’ve f*cked up somewhere in the process. The longer your ‘lag phase’ the more you’ve f*cked up. It doesn’t take f*cking days. [i]Fermentation[/i] takes days. The biggest f*ck ups are under pitching and low viability, which aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive f*ck ups. The main aim is to pitch sufficient (lots of) healthy yeast cells. There aren’t any magic one-size-fits-all pitching rates* and home brewers are unlikely to be in a position to be ‘over pitching’.
*How the f*ck are you going to know, unless you have at least a microscope and you really know how to use it? :lol:
[/quote]
[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zneBZl5BLw[/youtube]
:lol:[/quote]



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Yeah, anyway, the so-called [i]lag phase[/i] is simply where the yeast cells need time to process the environmental change - sweet wort conditions - and remodel their transcriptome to synthesise the appropriate proteins (enzymes) to do their dirty deed. It takes a few to several hours under optimal conditions, being strain dependent. Any longer, you’ve f*cked up somewhere in the process. The longer your ‘lag phase’ the more you’ve f*cked up. It doesn’t take f*cking days. [i]Fermentation[/i] takes days. The biggest f*ck ups are under pitching and low viability, which aren’t necessarily mutually exclusive f*ck ups. The main aim is to pitch sufficient (lots of) healthy yeast cells. There aren’t any magic one-size-fits-all pitching rates* and home brewers are unlikely to be in a position to be ‘over pitching’.
*How the f*ck are you going to know, unless you have at least a microscope and you really know how to use it? :lol:
[/quote]
[youtube]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2zneBZl5BLw[/youtube]
:lol:[/quote]



Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Re: Was my yeast bad, should I complain?
I can just hear it now. My nipper: “OMG! OMFG! That’s just like you, dad. WTF! That’s f*cking funny as f*ck, dad.” My wife: FFS, John! Haven’t I f*cking told you all-f*cking-ready about swearing so f*cking much in front of the kids?” Daughter: “Mum! OMG! Mind your language. Seriously!” Me and nipper: [LOL!] Beer?” A typical night really.