First Wort Hopping

If you have a hop related question about International Bittering Units or alpha acid, post it here!
Post Reply
User avatar
Aleman
It's definitely Lock In Time
Posts: 6132
Joined: Sun Jun 03, 2007 11:56 am
Location: Mashing In Blackpool, Lancashire, UK

First Wort Hopping

Post by Aleman » Wed Sep 12, 2007 9:04 pm

Daab asked for my thoughts on FWH so here goes.

I first came across the technique around 10?? years or so ago from a big discussion on the HBD, where it was the latest 'Big Thing', it has been around for much longer than that and some German brewers had rediscovered it in some research of Narziss (IIRC). What the report showed was that in blind taste tests, drinkers were able to identify, and in fact preferred, the FWH beers consistantly. Sensory evaluation reports from the tasters were that the beer had a more rounded mellow hop profile and aroma. Of course what happened on the HBD was that everyone took it to assume that if you first wort hopped you beers they would have a good aroma.

The technique is fairly simple, you take your aroma addition and add it to the kettle as you start to run in the wort from the mash tun. the hops then sit around in the wort and the hop aroma is magically fixed with the more concentrated malt sugars, and this survives through to the final beer. Well obviously that proved not to be the case, and there were a lot of unhappy brewers around.

I found that it didn't give me massive hop aroma, BUT, I did notice a change in the hop profile, a more mellow bitterness, which I liked, and even better this carried over even with extremely harsh copper hops (like Target). I therefore use a modification of the process and add my High alpha bittering addition as first wort hops, and carry on using a flavour and aroma addition as before . . . Well not quite, I now add my aroma hops when the wort in the boiler has cooled to below 80C, and in the couple of trials brews so far (That have supposed to have an intentially big hop nose) the results have been very promising.

One important trick of FWH though is that the FW Hops must sit in the wort at no more than 80C until the boiler is full then you bring it up to boiling. You loose the effect If you start heating the wort as soon as the boiler element is covered.

Like all things this technique is not a 'silver bullet' that will make a massive difference to your beers, but once you have nailed the major factors down , it is one of those that will allow you to reach that little bit higher on the quality scale.

As for the science about how it works, I really am not even going to try to make a guess, I have a couple of theories about some of the things that are going on, but without access to a brewing lab with a HLPC Gas Chromatograph there is no way of knowing whats going on, and even with one you really are guessing at the reactions behind the scenes.I lost my access to such a lab a long time ago, and the brewery is now sadly demolished (I don't even think the name lives on :( ). Still it does sort of mean that my interest in the brewing process is now a lot more practical even if I do suddenly disappear into the stratosphere with some of my more esoteric theories :)

Comments and Criteques welcome :wall

mr bond

Re: First Wort Hopping

Post by mr bond » Thu Sep 13, 2007 8:00 am

TJB wrote:
I therefore use a modification of the process and add my High alpha bittering addition as first wort hops, and carry on using a flavour and aroma addition as before . . . Well not quite, I now add my aroma hops when the wort in the boiler has cooled to below 80C, and in the couple of trials brews so far (That have supposed to have an intentially big hop nose) the results have been very promising.
Wow that's exactly what I do or the same reasons as you too.
Works a treat IMHO

User avatar
Aleman
It's definitely Lock In Time
Posts: 6132
Joined: Sun Jun 03, 2007 11:56 am
Location: Mashing In Blackpool, Lancashire, UK

Post by Aleman » Thu Sep 13, 2007 6:30 pm

DaaB wrote:So you are adding your bittering hops with the wort from the mash tun and your aroma hops as the wort is cooling (below 80 deg c).
Correct
DaaB wrote:You mention that you chill from 90-50 deg c in 15 mins so the hops don't need to sit in the wort at 80 deg c for long ? Or is it just having them in the wort at below 80 deg c that is the key ?
I probably wasn't clear enough, I start the IC and get the wort down to 80C, then add the aroma hops, these of course sit in the wort until the kettle is drained, but because they were added to 'cool' wort the aroma isn't driven off to anywhere near the same extent as adding them at boiler switch off.
DaaB wrote:I haven't quite got my head around your cooling system yet, it looks like you are running the wort through the PC and returning it to the boiler with the IC in it ?
Neither have I :) The wort is run from the boiler through the pump and returned to the boiler, with the Immersion chiller in it (standard as per Jamil Zeina whatsit :) (This is the latest addition to the chilling setup) This works really well at getting the wort down from boiling to around 50C, and the added benefit is that the wort clears of break proteins very well. When I've got it cooled, I then open an valve on the return side and the wort is directed through the plate chiller to the FV. This is the thing I'm not really happy with as my little plate chiller just can't chill the wort effectively. The next brew I'm going to go back to my revamped Immersion chiller (22m of 10mm Copper in 3/4" Hose), and I doubt if I'll have any problems with chilling. I'm going to get one of those 12" By 5" plate chillers from Ebay (probably the 20 Plate model, postage is $67), which should more than do the job particularly if I run coolant through my small one with an ICE water recirc on the other side. But this year I want to finish the Keggereezer and need 5 or 6 taps
DaaB wrote:Out of interest, is this above and beyond what a good commercial brewery would do or is this something that is necessary to get a good quality aromatic beer ?
Way above and beyond :) Most breweries Use a good bucketful of aroma hops (fresh!) in the copper or a hop back while chilling, some of the good European breweries do use FWH, but mention it to a lot of the craftbrewers over here and you tend to get blank looks.

User avatar
Jim
Site Admin
Posts: 10312
Joined: Sun Aug 22, 2004 1:00 pm
Location: Washington, UK

Post by Jim » Thu Sep 13, 2007 8:30 pm

Interesting stuff, TJB. 8)

Have you experimented with adding hops to the fermenter at all? I've thought of doing this as an alternative to dry-hopping in the keg (saves having to worry about the hops clogging the tap or being in contact with the beer too long).
NURSE!! He's out of bed again!

JBK on Facebook
JBK on Twitter

User avatar
mixbrewery
Drunk as a Skunk
Posts: 831
Joined: Mon May 21, 2007 7:48 pm
Location: Hemel
Contact:

Post by mixbrewery » Thu Sep 13, 2007 8:55 pm

So is there a big difference in the aroma hops from pitching in at boil switch off compared to 80c. ?
I reckon most of us haven't even considered there would be a difference between the two temps and just go for the boil off method.
Suppose you could cut down on the quantity of hops as well.

Any ideas if the effects vary with different hops varieties.
Check out the beers we have for sale @ Mix Brewery

User avatar
flytact
Drunk as a Skunk
Posts: 759
Joined: Wed Oct 04, 2006 6:31 pm
Location: Annapolis, MD - USA

Post by flytact » Fri Sep 14, 2007 1:03 pm

There was a post earlier in the week about this very subject with an attached article. I'd love to direct you to it, but it's a rare day where I actually will be working at work and haven't the time. :D
Johnny Clueless was there
With his simulated wood grain

Post Reply