I did a side-by-side tasting tonight with carry out Hophead from the brewery in Partridge Green.
I considered a few criteria:
Colour
Bitterness
Malt Flavour
Body
Hop flavour
Aroma
Colour, I saw as light yellow almost strawlike. I have a match.
Bitterness I thought of as the initial hit on sipping and the lingering after taste bitterness. I have a match here too.
Maltiness should be low, the brewery use low colour maris otter and a little cara, I used standard maris otter and cara, I couldn't discern any difference, a match here.
Body, my beer is a smidge more solid, it's not sweetness, it's the body after initial sip before the aftertaste. The brewery beer is lighter - more hollow. Any thought? Maybe check mash temp is no higher than say 66, and/or down caramalt to 4%?
Hop flavour, I have a little too much citrus hop flavour, easily remedied by moving hops later not before 10mins from the end I reckon.
Aroma, this is the area where I can notice a difference, maybe force carbinating doesn't help but I've not got the same level of aroma as the brewery. So I plan to stir a greater amount of hops in during chilling with the immersion cooler.
Two final notes are that the brewery make a small bittering charge at the beginning of the boil so I will do the same, freeing up hops for use later on. Also a comment on the yeast contribution. I used WLP001, for my palate that was spot on. However I want to acheive the corrected brew with Safale US-05 as I hear that's a yeast the use at Dark Star, and of course dried yeasts are less hassle!
Had a non-ale drinker taste them side by side, and despite their lack of interest in what I was doing they said they tasted very similar...for what it's worth
