The only time I have brewed the same brew twice was a coopers stout. Even then I brewed them differently. One had a bottle of ginger wine added, the other several pots of coffee.
Now, while I predominantly brew stouts, I still never follow the same recipe twice. The closest I will get is a modified version of my favourite (to date) stout recipe which I may eventually brew if I get through my backlog of recipes to try!
I personally think that there are far too many different beers in existence to stick to one type all the time. Since I can't get to most of the beers to try them, I will settle for always making a different beer when I can
I may one day stumble upon that amazing recipe that I want again and again. Till I do, Always something different.
maxashton wrote:
For this reason, i'd love to get into AG, but just don't have the space.

You don't really need much more space. I am using a bucket in bucket mashtun which stack inside each other. I take the tape and element off my boiler which then stacks inside the mashtun. Then there is the fermenter which is the same type of bucket as the mashtun is made from. Most other things then go inside the boiler. Everything stakced neatly away in the same amount of space, just a little higher....
You can also just get the right amount of grain for each individual brew (assuming you can get locally - wouldn't be cost effective if mail order due to P&P)