To bump this thread then:
Right. So I didn't leave my Nog long (2 weeks in bottles - really impressed with s-04's performace) but I thought I'd have a quick sample and it tastes almost the same as my Wherry, which tasted almost the same as the kit before that which... anyway... I hadn't really found the forum up until the Nog and for that kit used a campden tablet in my tap water. There has been no discernable change, ie there is still an off flavour that has been present in all my previous brews. Is it likely to be something else? Is there a simple list of rank flavours in beer?
My Dad isn't bothered by it and says yeah that's good homebrew that is. He thinks that having it sit on the (inactive) yeast for too long may lead to off-flavours. He has no experience but was just relaying information from the old Marston's brewery tour, that they brewed it quick, but they're commercial and want it in the pub as soon as possible, they're losing money on it when it ferments so I'm not convinced it's necessarily better or even different to leave it settle a bit. Either way for me it's an obnoxious smell and flavour that's really putting me off brewing much more. If I can't solve what's going wrong for a kit how do I stand a chance at making a full mash brew taste half decent with a load more variables to worry about?
Without a decent vocabulary I feel ill-equiped to fully describe what I can taste. Might nip along to a local micro and see if they have a friendly brewer who uses the same water as me.
So, I've added the campden, will certainly swill the FV out with a campden solution next time too just as a multiple redundancy thing but can't see that having much effect. Any other suggestions? Could it just need longer to condition?
Sorry for rambling, but the fact it's consistent across kits must mean it's something I'm doing wrong which is, to be honest, more than a little embarassing
